As someone who’s moved eight times within the last eight years, I know a thing or two about closet systems. Some apartments just don’t have the space I desperately need to store my shoes, dresses, and coats (I have many, many coats). I’ve had to get pretty creative over the years.

To find the best options, BHG tested several closet systems to see how annoying they are to install, how much weight they can hold, and whether they feel sturdy or cheap. I analyzed the data and used my own high standards to figure out which ones are truly worth your time and money.

Top Picks

BEST OVERALL:

The Container Store Elfa Classic 4 Foot Closet Kit at Container Store $300

Jump to Review

BEST BUDGET:

Amazon Basics Expandable Storage Organizer Rack at Amazon $115

Jump to Review

BEST WOOD:

allen+roth Hartford Solid Shelving Wood Closet System at Lowes $409

Jump to Review

BEST MODULAR:

IKEA Boaxel Wardrobe Combination at Ikea $262

Jump to Review

BEST REACH-IN CLOSET:

ClosetMaid SuiteSymphony Closet System at Amazon $474

Jump to Review

BEST FOR RENTERS:

ClosetMaid 8809 ShelfTrack Closet System at Amazon $185

Jump to Review

BEST FOR SMALL APARTMENTS:

Homykic Bamboo Closet System at Amazon $196

Jump to Review

BEST FOR KIDS’ BEDROOMS:

SALE Homykic Medium Closet System at Amazon $166 $138

Jump to Review

What We Tested

Our team tested more than 10 closet systems in our own homes to see how well they handle real-world wear and tear. For more information on how we tested closet systems, check out our testing process below.

BEST OVERALL

The Container Store Elfa Classic 4 Foot Closet Kit

Credit: The Container Store

$300 at Container Store

Why You Should Get It

• It’s sturdy, doesn't bow under heavy weight, and is easy to customize or expand as your storage needs change.

Keep in Mind

• The hanging rods don't sit entirely flush inside the brackets.

The Elfa Classic 4-Foot Closet Kit is our top pick because it’s the only system we tested that feels like a permanent upgrade. After six months of daily use, it’s as sturdy as it was on day one, and the rods haven’t bowed under the weight. 

Set aside about two hours for setup. It’s a great project for beginner to intermediate DIYers since the physical assembly is fairly straightforward. Just be prepared to pull the instructions up on your phone or print them out beforehand, as the kit doesn’t come with a paper manual.

It’s definitely on the pricier side for a metal system, but it’s strong and easy to expand with custom pieces later if you need more space. The Container Store sells individual components, extra matching drawers, and standalone wire shelves. 

It’s customizable, and you can easily adjust the shelves and rods whenever your storage needs change. The clear bins are also great since you can see what’s inside without having to dig around. 

Our only real complaint is that one of the plastic shoe boxes arrived with a small chip that messed with the hinge, and the closet rods don’t fit fully into the brackets, which makes them feel a little too short. 

Buy If:

• You want a permanent-feeling upgrade for your closet.
• Your budget is flexible. This is an investment compared to simple wire rack organizers or basic standalone clothing racks.

Product Details: Dimensions: 50 x 84 x 17 in. | Material: Epoxy steel | Weight Capacity: 100 lbs. per linear foot (ventilated shelf); 70 lbs. per linear foot (hanging rack/rods) | Cost Per Linear Foot: $126.75

• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens

BEST BUDGET

Amazon Basics Expandable Storage Organizer Rack

Credit: Amazon

$115 at Amazon

Why You Should Get It

• It only takes 30 minutes to assemble and is strong enough to hold heavy gear without wobbling.

Keep in Mind

• Replacement parts are not available.

The Amazon Basics Expandable Metal Rack is our top budget pick because it gives you tons of heavy-duty, customizable storage without the steep price tag. We tested this freestanding unit in a dance and gymnastics practice area, where it holds everything from costumes to sports equipment. 

The steel construction is solid and secure and can handle bulky items like luggage on the top rack without any shaking or swaying. This is the perfect project for a beginner DIYer. It took just 30 minutes for one person to put together, relying on basic assembly skills to slide and lock the pieces smoothly into place. 

The design lets you change the shelf heights and slide the hanging rods out to fit whatever you need to store. It also comes with leveling feet, which are helpful if your floors are uneven. After six months of constant daily use, our tester is still raving about how durable it feels.

The only real downside is that it looks like industrial shelving. It only comes in black, and since it doesn’t have enclosed drawers, all your items are on display. It might not be the prettiest choice for a primary bedroom, but its strength, flexibility, and low price make it a great deal for a storage space or hobby room.

Note that if a component bends or gets lost over time, Amazon Basics doesn’t sell individual replacement parts or extra matching metal shelves for this specific system, so you’ll need to stick with the configuration out of the box.

Buy If:

• You need heavy-duty, customizable storage for a closet or hobby room.
• An upscale aesthetic is not your priority. The industrial design looks closer to commercial warehouse or utility room shelving than custom furniture.
• You’re prepared to replace the whole unit if there’s a problem later. Extra shelves or custom components can’t be purchased individually.

Product Details: Dimensions: 14 x 80 x 72 in. | Material: Alloy steel, plastic | Weight Capacity: Up to 1,299 lbs. total | Cost Per Linear Foot: $10.34

• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens

BEST WOOD

allen+roth Hartford Solid Shelving Wood Closet System

Credit: Lowe's

$409 at Lowes

Why You Should Get It

• It looks like a high-end custom built-in without the hefty price tag, features smooth soft-close drawers, and offers plenty of hanging storage that grows with a child.

Keep in Mind

• You have to anchor it to studs, so you can't just center it anywhere you want.

The allen + roth Hartford Kit is our choice for the best wood system because it gives you the upscale look of custom built-ins for a fraction of the price. We put this together in a child’s closet with accordion doors to organize clothes and toys. 

It looks great alongside existing bedroom furniture and feels solid, especially the soft-close drawer which still operates smoothly after six months of daily use. It’s a sturdy, visually appealing upgrade that will easily transition from holding toddler toys to hanging a teenager’s wardrobe. 

Prepare yourself for a lengthy installation process that definitely isn’t for beginners; assembly took our tester six hours. You’ll need advanced DIY skills, a stud finder, a screwdriver, and a ratchet set—plus, you might even have to use a saw to trim down a few pieces for a perfect fit. 

Since the main tower has to anchor directly into your wall studs, you lose some flexibility on where you can position the unit in your closet space. We also noticed a strong wood glue and chemical odor right after unboxing, though it did fade away over time.

The system blends real wood with MDF parts, and while the MDF sections can dent if you knock them around hard enough during setup, any marks our tester made are barely noticeable. The unit gives you a great balance of shelving, shoe slots, and an extendable hanging rod. 

If you want to expand or customize the configuration later, individual components like extra Hartford solid shelves, towers, and matching drawer units can be purchased separately at Lowe’s.

Buy If:

• You want flexible storage that can shift with your changing needs.
• You have DIY experience. You’ll need to be comfortable using a stud finder, socket set, and wood saw.
• You don’t need 100% solid wood. The design uses a mix of real wood and engineered MDF panels.

Product Details: Dimensions: 96 x 76 x 16 in. | Material: Wood, MDF | Weight Capacity: 25 lbs. (shelves) | Cost Per Linear Foot: $44.88

• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens

BEST MODULAR

IKEA Boaxel Wardrobe Combination

Credit: IKEA

$262 at Ikea

Why You Should Get It

• The shelves, rods, and baskets are easy to move around as your needs change, and the deep shelves easily fit shoes and folded clothes.

Keep in Mind

• It doesn't include any mounting screws or wall anchors, and you'll need to buy extra brackets if you want to hang every part in the box.

IKEA’s Boaxel system is our pick for the best modular design because it gives you total flexibility to rearrange the layout of your closet. We tested this unit in a small reach-in closet with sliding doors, using it first for a spare bedroom and later for a child’s clothes. 

The setup includes six shelves and six mesh baskets, which store so many clothes that it eliminates the need for a separate dresser in our tester’s bedroom. The drawers slide and lift out of their brackets smoothly, and the shelves are deep enough to fit a man’s size 14 shoe. 

Expect to spend about three hours on setup, which is best suited for intermediate DIYers. Honestly, the installation is the most frustrating part of this system. The instructions are unclear and feel out of order. It also doesn’t include the basic mounting hardware you need to install it.

You have to buy your own drywall anchors, drywall screws, and wood screws, depending on your wall type. You’ll also have to buy the missing brackets separately for $2 each—and we needed six more just to use everything in the box.

If you can get past the annoying assembly and missing parts, the day-to-day use is tough to beat. Six months into testing, our tester still loves it and even plans to add another unit to her nursery. 

Since the configuration is so adaptable, you can lower the components to match a child’s height or buy extra shelves and baskets if you move to a home with a bigger closet. If you want to modify your layout, individual replacement parts and extra components can be purchased separately online or in-store.

Buy If:

• You need a lot of flexibility and room for a big wardrobe.
• You don’t mind patching drywall later. Mounting the configuration requires drilling multiple permanent holes.

Product Details: Dimensions: 16 x 49 x 79 in. | Material: Steel, plastic, particleboard | Weight Capacity: Not listed | Cost Per Linear Foot: $64.06

• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens

BEST REACH-IN CLOSET

ClosetMaid SuiteSymphony Closet System

Credit: Wayfair

$474 at Amazon

$473 at Wayfair

Why You Should Get It

• It features solid, flat shelves that keep items from slipping through, and adjustable hanging rods that expand to fit layouts up to 10 feet wide.

Keep in Mind

• The manufactured wood feels a bit cheap, and the drawers tend to catch rather than glide smoothly.

The ClosetMaid SuiteSymphony is our top pick for reach-in closets because its adjustable rods expand to fit awkward or wide layouts. We tested this organizer in a walk-in closet. The layout features a center tower with three adjustable shelves and three enclosed drawers, flanked by three hanging rods. 

We love how it splits up your wardrobe: one side has two rods for shorter items like shirts, while the other side features a single high rod for long dresses and coats. The drawers help prevent small items like socks and tank tops from slipping out the sides, though they catch a bit on their tracks.

Our tester is less impressed with the material’s durability. A few pieces arrived cracked and chipped out of the box, and you have to be careful not to bump the manufactured wood during assembly since it nicks easily. However, six months into testing, it’s still holding up, and the rods haven’t bowed.

Set aside about four hours (and recruit a friend) for assembly. It’s an intermediate project that would be a nightmare to handle alone, mostly because you have to lift and align heavy, stacked pieces to assemble the center tower. You need a drill, screwdrivers, a tape measure, and a level. 

Double-check exactly where you want your hanging rods to sit before you start drilling. If you want to swap things around later, ClosetMaid sells matching standalone SuiteSymphony drawers, top shelves, and doors separately, so you can modify your layout as needed

Buy If:

• You have a buddy to help with installation. Assembling and lifting the stacked center tower pieces requires two people to align everything safely.
• You’re on the taller side. The upper shelves on this tower layout can be quite difficult to reach comfortably without a step stool.
• You have a large closet. If space is restricted, you must be strategic about where you anchor the center tower, or the protruding drawer handles may obstruct your closet door.

Product Details: Dimensions: 14.7 x 120 x 82.5 in. | Material: Manufactured wood | Weight Capacity: Not listed | Cost Per Linear Foot: $14.32

• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens

BEST FOR RENTERS

ClosetMaid 8809 ShelfTrack Closet System

Credit: Amazon

$185 at Amazon

Why You Should Get It

• It’s easily customizable, compatible with extra ClosetMaid accessories, and quick and easy for one person to install.

Keep in Mind

• The wire shelving allows small items to slip through.

The ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Organizer is our top choice for anyone whose storage needs are constantly changing, like long-term renters or parents updating a kid’s closet. We tested it in a shared walk-in closet to organize a large collection of clothing and shoes, replacing a basic single-rod setup. 

The ability to customize the layout allows our tester to fit way more items into a much tighter arrangement. The adjustable racks and shelves move as your wardrobe shifts over time. Since ClosetMaid is a national brand, you can purchase extra compatible parts or accessories at most big-box hardware stores.

The only real drawback to the design is the wire material itself. It doesn’t feel as premium or durable as solid wood, and smaller items will slip right through the gaps, though it works great for larger boxes and bulky shoes.

This is a great weekend project, for a beginner. One person can complete the installation from start to finish in about an hour. The instructions are clear and simple to understand. You’ll need a drill, a level, and a stud finder, as the main tracks must be secured directly into your wall studs. 

We installed this in an older home with unevenly spaced studs, so our tester had to drill a couple of extra holes in the anchor piece to ensure it was secure. Despite that minor hurdle, everything locked together nicely and felt stable once assembled.

Buy If:

• You need to fit a lot of items in a limited space.
• You don’t mind an industrial aesthetic. The basic vinyl-coated metal looks utilitarian rather than like high-end furniture or built-ins. 
• You can drill into wall studs. It requires anchoring the main rails securely into the structural studs.

Product Details: Dimensions: 13 x 96 x 84 in. | Material: Vinyl-coated steel | Weight Capacity: Not listed | Cost Per Linear Foot: $23.12

• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens

BEST FOR SMALL APARTMENTS

Homykic Bamboo Closet System

Credit: Amazon

$196 at Amazon

Why You Should Get It

• It has five hanging rods, multiple shelves, and all the tools you need for assembly.

Keep in Mind

• The vertical space isn’t tall enough to hang long dresses.

The Homykic Bamboo Closet System (Large) is a great value for someone who needs extra hanging and shelf space but can’t drill into their walls. We tested this freestanding rack in the corner of a bedroom to supplement a tiny, overcrowded closet. 

The layout features five hanging rods along with top, bottom, and side shelving, giving our tester plenty of space to organize blouses, skirts, pants, and sweaters. It’s great for separating their wardrobe by clothing type, and they even store purses, belts, and shoes on the open shelves. 

While the bamboo material does feel a bit cheap, it solved our tester’s storage problem and works well alongside other units from the same brand if you want to run them side by side to create a larger wardrobe wall.

Plan to grab a friend and spend about an hour on this project. It’s an approachable setup for beginners. The brand includes all the necessary hardware and a screwdriver right in the box, and the instructions are clear with detailed photos to guide you. 

Unlike the other wall-mounted systems we tested, this rack only goes together one way—so you just build it exactly as it appears in the picture, without having to map out where the shelves go. Our tester’s primary complaint is that the vertical space isn’t long enough to hang long dresses.

Buy If:

• You don’t own a lot of long items. The hanging rods only provide enough vertical clearance for shorter garments like shirts, skirts, and short dresses.
• A custom layout isn’t a must-have. The configuration cannot be adjusted or customized once assembled.
• You have hard floors or thin carpeting. The freestanding frame feels noticeably less sturdy on carpet than it does on solid hard flooring.

Product Details: Dimensions: 15.75 x 70.28 x 78.74 in. | Material: Bamboo | Weight Capacity: Up to 668 lbs. | Cost Per Linear Foot: $26.97

• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens

BEST FOR KIDS’ BEDROOMS

Homykic Medium Closet System

Credit: Amazon

$166

$138 at Amazon

Why You Should Get It

• It adds meaningful storage to a small space, and includes all the necessary setup materials.

Keep in Mind

• Our tester’s instruction manual was printed out of order.

The Homykic Bamboo Closet System (Medium) is a great, lightweight option for expanding your storage if you don’t have enough room to fit everything in a tiny closet. We set it up in a bedroom corner to handle the overflow from a crowded closet. 

Multiple hanging rods make it easy to separate your wardrobe by clothing type, and the open shelving gives you a great view of folded pants and shorts. However, the durability feels a bit weak. 

Our tester actually heard a cracking sound when they put some body weight on the lowest shelf while reaching for the back, though there was no visible damage.

You can definitely tackle this project alone, though grabbing a friend will make it go faster. Expect the setup to take about 90 minutes. The brand includes all the materials you need right in the box, but we hit a frustrating snag: the pages of the instruction manual were printed out of order. 

Since the steps have to be completed in a specific sequence, this oversight caused some confusion and definitely extended setup time once our tester realized the mistake. Like the larger version, this rack only goes together one way, so you just build it exactly how it looks in the picture.

Buy If:

• You want supplemental storage. This isn’t sturdy or large enough to replace a full master closet system.
• You’re hanging mostly short garments. The compact layout doesn’t include a long vertical area for hanging full-length dresses.
• You don’t mind open storage. The open bamboo frame doesn’t include any drawers to hide smaller items or undergarments.

Product Details: Dimensions: 16.2 x 41.4 x 78.8 in. | Material: Bamboo | Weight Capacity: Up to 450 lbs. total | Cost Per Linear Foot: $39.99

• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
• Credit: Better Homes & Gardens

The Bottom Line

Our top pick overall is the Elfa Classic 4’ Closet Starter Kit. It feels like a permanent, high-quality upgrade that adapts to your changing wardrobe over time. If you’re on a tight budget, the Amazon Basics Expandable Metal Rack is sturdy and takes only 30 minutes to set up, though lacks that built-in, custom-cabinetry aesthetic.

Our Testing Process 

To find the best closet systems, our team tested more than 10 models in our actual homes over the course of six months.

We started by timing and grading the installation process right out of the box. We noted whether the instructions made sense, how many people it took to safely lift the pieces, and whether the brands included the necessary mounting hardware or left us running to the hardware store for drywall anchors.

After assembly, we loaded the units up with our personal wardrobes. We monitored each system daily for a full six months, looking for any signs of bowing hanging rods, chipped manufactured wood, or drawers catching on their tracks. We also evaluated how simple it was to customize or expand the layouts over time. 

The ultimate deciding factor came down to comparing the overall durability and storage capacity against the retail price to determine if the systems were genuinely worth the investment.

Better Homes & Gardens

What to Know About Closet Systems Before Shopping

Material

The most common materials you’ll find among closet systems are metal or wood, which often tends to be medium-density fiberboard (MDF). Cara Palmer, founder of Organize Every Room, says that wood systems offer an aesthetic appeal with durability, but the cost tends to be higher.

MDF, or engineered wood, is more affordable but not as strong as wood, and may be more susceptible to moisture damage. Metal shelving is durable and good for heavier objects when you want a closet system that will last. “They promote air circulation (good for humid environments), but smaller items can fall through and look less refined,” Palmer says.

Julie Morgenstern, author of multiple organizing and time management books, including Organizing From The Inside Out, suggests avoiding coated wire or metal wire shelving systems for clothing because they can catch on fabric. Plus, the wire prevents stacks of clothes from staying neat and organized. “The key is to make sure the surface is completely flat,” she says.

Customization & Configuration

Choosing the right configuration ultimately comes down to what you’re planning to store. In general, Morgenstern says a mix of drawers, shelves, and hanging poles serve most people best. Drawers work well for small items like socks and small purses while shelves are ideal for folded tops and pants. Hanging space is best for storing slacks, dresses, tops, and suits. 

To get an idea of what configuration you might need, take inventory of your belongings and measure your space. “Stack your T-shirts, sweaters, and folded pants on the bed in stacks about 10 to 12 inches high. Count the number of stacks and measure them to get an idea of how much shelf space you’ll need,” Morgenstern says.

You can also group items you plan to stash in a drawer. Place them on a bed or other surface based on how you’d like to store them, then determine how many drawers you’ll need and how tall they should be. To plan hanging space, hang the clothes on an existing rod and measure the linear feet they take up. “Always plan on allowing some extra space to allow for breathing room in your closet,” Morgenstern says.

Generally, we preferred modular options like the Elfa unit or IKEA kits for their configuration possibilities. Both of these products also offer the option to purchase additional items to further customize closet space as needed.

Better Homes & Gardens

Weight Capacity

Palmer advises that shelving for clothes should have a weight capacity of 30 to 40 pounds per linear foot, at minimum. She adds, “Hanging rods should support 30-plus pounds per foot for versatility with heavier items like winter coats.” 

If you’re organizing a utility closet, aim for a closet system that can handle at least 50 pounds per shelf. That way, you can easily store heavier objects like tools or other household supplies, according to Palmer. 

Who We Are

Tabitha Britt is a Better Homes & Gardens contributor who’s moved eight times in the last eight years, making her a pro at dealing with less-than-ideal closet spaces. She personally tested a system for this piece—but ultimately disqualified it for not meeting her strict standards. To finalize these top picks, she dug into real-world data from our team of testers to determine which units are worth your time, money, and effort.

This article also features original reporting by Brittany VanDerBill and expert advice from Julie Morgenstern, author of multiple organizing and time management books, including Organizing From The Inside Out, and Cara Palmer, founder of Organize Every Room.